Review: A Secret Gift by Ted Gup

Subtitle: How One Man’s Kindness – and a Trove of Letters – Revealed the Hidden History of the Great Depression

Sam Stone was a man of mystery, able to sever relationships with his own siblings, but also capable of enormous compassion and generosity toward total strangers. The author is Sam Stone’s grandson, an investigative reporter and journalism professor. Twenty-seven years after his grandfather’s death, Ted Gup’s mother gives him old suitcases with family papers. In it is a packet of letters regarding “Xmas Gift Distribution.”

Just before Christmas in 1933, Sam (using the alias “B. Virdot”) placed an ad in a Canton, Ohio, newspaper saying that he will give to 75 families the sum of $10, and asking those who could use the help to write to him at a post office box in the city. Sam amended his offer to giving $5 each to 150 people after an overwhelming response. The letters are from the people who received checks from “B. Virdot.”

Ted Gup goes on to research the people in the letters and their descendants – and his grandfather’s mysterious past. A Secret Gift is the result.

At first, I thought the subtitle, claiming that the letters tell “the hidden history of the great depression,” was an overstatement. But after reading A Secret Gift, I felt as if I understood for the first time how the Great Depression affected ordinary people.

Being an amateur genealogist myself, I realize what a huge job the author took on when he researched what happened to the families his grandfather helped, generations later. I don’t want to give away too much about this wonderful book – just a wish that everyone read it and absorb its lessons. In an age that often seems devoid of compassion (just listen to the politicians!), A Secret Gift is an antidote to that affliction.

Posted in Book Reviews, Non-Fiction, Genealogy, History | Tagged , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Review: Newspaper Titan by Amanda Smith

Subtitle: The Infamous Life and Monumental Times of Cissy Patterson

Eleanor Medill Patterson (1881-1948) was high maintenance, high drama and spent more money each year than most people manage to accumulate in a lifetime. She acquired as many enemies as she did friends, and they were often the same people. But she knew how to run a profitable newspaper.

She never coveted journalism prizes and, like her cousins “Captain” Joseph Patterson (New York Daily News) and “Colonel” Robert McCormick (Chicago Tribune), she used her newspaper to reward her friends and skewer her enemies. Politically the newspaper she owned and published, the Washington Times-Herald, was more conservative than any of today’s screamers, anti-FDR and pro-Nazi. But she was interesting.

One of four grandchildren of Joseph Medill, for whom the Northwestern University school of journalism is named, she married and divorced a minor Eastern European count, had one child whom she ignored, and a beloved granddaughter she eventually turned on. But she was the daughter and niece of Medill’s two battling daughters who never let up on each other or “Cissy,” and her muddled emotional life was totally understandable.

Amanda Smith has put together a well researched and well sourced biography of “Cissy” that weighs in at 696 pages.  I can’t say I tore through it – it’s not that kind of book – but I found the entire book fascinating and easy to get through. The most interesting pages were those devoted to the months after Cissy died and the fight over her considerable estate. Throughout the book, the author translates any dollar amounts of other years into today’s dollars, using two different calculations. That helps put Ms. Patterson’s earning capability and profligate spending into perspective.

Newspaper Titan makes for reading that’s every bit as trashy and titillating as a good gossip column, but with back-notes.

Posted in Biography, Book Reviews, Non-Fiction, Journalism | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Review: Late Edition by Bob Greene

Subtitle: A Love Story

Bob Greene was one of those lucky people who knew from a young age what he wanted to be when he grew up: a newspaper reporter. And he couldn’t have picked a better time to have grown up with that dream than the 1960s and 1970s. Late Edition is the story of how he began his career in journalism working Columbus (Ohio) Citizen-Journal.

His first article submission (unsuccessful as it turned out) was in November 1963, when he wrote a remembrance of a particular high-school day, the day JFK was shot. He persisted, and eventually was hired for summer work, first as a copy-boy, then a sports writer, then a general assignment reporter. Eventually, he graduated from Northwestern University, was hired by the Chicago Tribune, and became, at age 23, a columnist for the Trib: a decided over-achiever.

But it’s his early days in Columbus that are the focus of Late Edition – and it’s definitely a “Love Story” as the subtitle suggests. Urged, as a future journalist, to keep a journal of his experiences and thoughts, he mines that material for an incredibly detailed story of clattering typewriters, ink-stained printers in paper hats and cigarette smoke: the sights, sounds and smells of a newsroom that doesn’t exist except in memory these days.

Bob Greene is not the world’s most concise writer, and he seems to go over the same territory more than once. But he recreates the feel of another era, a nostalgic look back at what was, a remembrance of the day when every family subscribed to at least one newspaper. A very satisfying read.

Posted in Biography, History, Journalism, Memoir | Tagged , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Review: King Peggy by Peggielene Bartels and Eleanor Herman (Feb 2012)

Subtitle: An American Secretary, Her Royal Destiny, and the Inspiring Story of How She Changed an African Village

At first, Peggy Bartels thought it was a joke. The 2008 phone call from her native Ghana delivered the news that she had been selected King of Otuam, an impoverished fishing village of a few thousand souls. There she was: a secretary in the Ghanaian embassy in Washington, D.C., an American citizen, the owner of a condo with a mortgage that was under water.

Otuam had been ruled by her late Uncle Joseph, so poor that Peggy sent him money every month to help him get by. The royal palace was in ruins and, as King Peggy soon found out, the council of elders that ruled the village was corrupt to its core. And the treasury had a zero balance. The financial burden of rehabbing the palace – required so as not to dishonor her ancestors – and giving the late King a spectacular funereal send-off would be on Peggy’s shoulders.

Leaving a trusted cousin in place as her regent while she returns to America, Peggy agonizes over how she is going to provide running water to her village, build a high school, fund a library – and pave the potholed roads. King Peggy is a story of her first two years as king.

Although the book blurb compared King to Alexander McCall Smith’s African detective Precious Ramotswe, King Peggy is in a category all by herself, one that she needn’t share with a fictional character. No, King Peggy is the real deal.

This book is definitely an autobiography, but it’s written in third person, which I found odd at first.  But King Peggy gives readers a snapshot of a culture that’s worlds away from ours in America. We may read about Africa in newspapers, see it on the news –King Peggy provides much more insight into the lives of ordinary Ghanaians, and the extraordinary life of one of its kings.

Review based on published-provided copy of King Peggy.

Posted in Biography, Book Reviews, Non-Fiction | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

Review: Hometown Appetites by Kelly Alexander and Cynthia Harris

Subtitle: The Story of Clementine Paddleford, the Forgotten Food Writer Who Chronicled How America Ate

Born just before the turn of the last century, Clementine Paddleford graduated from college in her home state of Kansas, went to New York City to make her way as a writer, became a famous and accomplished newspaperwoman and expert on American regional cooking, died, and then faded into obscurity. The authors, a New York magazine editor/writer and a Kansas librarian, join forces to resurrect Clementine Paddleford and her legacy.

Hometown Appetites is a wonderful story, researched to the nth degree, and beautifully written by two women who approach their task and their subject with respect and affection. What a story! How I have gone through life without ever hearing of Clementine Paddleford is amazing to me.

Now that I know about Ms. Paddleford, I’m on the lookout for a copy of her 1960 book, How America Eats. Who knows? Maybe this biography will prompt a resurgence of interest in her books and columns.

Posted in Biography, Book Reviews, Non-Fiction, Food, History, Journalism | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Review: Fiction Ruined My Family by Jeanne Darst

It’s best to not know too much about Fiction Ruined My Family before jumping in. (I bought it because it was 50% off at Barnes & Noble and I liked the title.) The Darsts are an exquisitely dysfunctional family: dad, a failed writer; mom, a sometimes lovable lush; four daughters. “Normal” is never in the cards for them.

Jeanne is the youngest. She is bawdy, profane and funny.

Fiction Ruined My Family is not my normal cup of tea. But reading it was like rubber-necking at a train wreck. I couldn’t help myself.

Posted in Book Reviews, Non-Fiction, Memoir | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Review: Three-Day Town by Margaret Maron

North Carolina Judge Deborah Knott and hubby Dwight Bryant, a high-ranking police official, head from Colleton County to the Big Apple for a much-delayed honeymoon. They’re staying gratis in the Manhattan co-op apartment of Dwight’s sister-in-law. While they’re at a neighbor’s party, a man is killed in their apartment, bringing in Sigrid Harald, a NYPD lieutenant. By coincidence, Judge Knott is delivering a wrapped package to Sigrid for her to give to her mother; the package is from Sigrid’s grandmother, who lives in Colleton County NC. (Sigrid Harald is another of Margaret Maron’s series characters.)

Three-Day Town is written mostly from the viewpoints of two narrators, one concerned with Judge Knott’s doings, the other with Lt. Harald’s – so while readers see both, the protagonists know only their own. Ms. Maron handles those viewpoints in her usual masterful fashion, but I didn’t care much for that approach. I also would prefer to find Deborah and Dwight back on their home turf, but I understand that authors need variety in their writing and Three-Day Town certainly provides it.

I thought the sub-plot involving the mysterious, wrapped package to be somewhat distracting – and the resolution of that plot thread a bit disappointing. Still, this series remains one of my long-time favorites – and Three-Day Town was a good read from a wonderful writer.

Posted in Book Reviews, Fiction | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Review: News to Me by Laurie Hertzel

Subtitle: Adventures of an Accidental Journalist

News to Me is a memoir by a Minnesota journalist about her 18 years at the Duluth News-Tribune – and a wonderful memoir it is. Although she documents the rise and fall of an American newspaper, this is a more personal story. And if News to Me isn’t the best memoir I’ve read, I can’t really think of one that tops it. Maybe that makes it the best. (And I’ve read a ton of memoirs and autobiographies of journalists, most of them much more famous than the author.)

Laurie Hertzel knows how to tell a story and how to avoid the twin traps of telling too much or telling too little. In News to Me, she gets it just right. Ms. Hertzel is funny and introspective, self-confident and self-deprecating.  This book is so good, I may just read it again someday.

Although journalists might be more attracted to News to Me, I believe any reader would appreciate Laurie’s story and storytelling … I especially enjoyed the story of her reporting trip to Russia. And her love for Duluth and its environs comes through on every page. When it comes out in trade paperback, I’ll recommend it for my non-fiction book group’s selections.

Posted in Biography, Book Reviews, Non-Fiction, Journalism, Memoir | Tagged , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Review: Hedy’s Folly by Richard Rhodes

Subtitle: The Life and Breakthrough Inventions of Hedy Lamarr, the Most Beautiful Woman in the World

I remember hearing somewhere that Hedy Lamarr held some important patents that she gave to the US government. Hedy’s Folly tells the story of how a glamorous film star came to be an inventor. According to the book, starring in Hollywood movies was her day job, one that enabled her to indulge in her true passion: invention. She grew up a curious child with an indulgent father who took her on long walks during which he would explain how things worked. Then she married a wealthy Austrian man whose family business was armaments – war weaponry that would eventually be sold to the Nazis in World War II.

“Any girl can be glamorous. All you have to do is stand still and look stupid,” she is quoted as saying. And while she was married to her controlling first husband, she was the docile wife, great at entertaining; over dinner, she sat still and soaked it all in all the war talk.

Natural curiosity, education and the knowledge she obtained over dinner helped Ms. Lamarr make good use of her drafting table once she arrived in the U.S.  The invention that was the capstone of her inventing career was one that involved radio frequencies … creating a mechanism that would make radio-controlled torpedoes invulnerable to jamming.  Her collaborator was George Antheil, a tradition-breaking composer.

Although Hedy’s Folly is a short book, just over 200 pages of text, I thought it was too long. The story, which I’ll admit is interesting, would have been better as an article in a Sunday magazine. I thought the author spent too much time on Hedy’s inventing partner, his life and times – and not enough on really explaining Hedy’s inventions. Richard Rhodes is an established and award-winning non-fiction author. I guess I expected more from his book.

Posted in Biography, Book Reviews, Non-Fiction, History | Tagged , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Review: The Time Traveler’s Guide to Medieval England by Ian Mortimer

Subtitle: A Handbook for Visitors to the Fourteenth Century

Although I’m a great fan of fictional time-travel stories (Connie Willis is my favorite author in that genre), this is not a book I would have read had it not been a selection by a non-fiction readers’ group of which I’m a member. What fun it was … and I’m glad I didn’t miss it.

I didn’t need to read any book to know I wouldn’t have relished living in the Middle Ages. Talk about a tough life!  The Time Traveler’s Guide to Medieval England gives it to readers chapter and verse. From clothing (dictated by one’s class) to the legal climate (grim for civil liberties), food (surprisingly varied) to health and hygiene (ugh!), Ian Mortimer shows what life was like in the 1300s. Although a few people are named, for the most part The Time Traveler’s Guide to Medieval England has no characters.

(While I was reading this book, I kept on thinking how an historian eight centuries from now would write such a book about the US in our current century. What a job that would be!)

The Time Traveler’s Guide to Medieval England would make a wonderful supplementary text for a European History class. I have to hand it to Ian Mortimer – he tells such a wonderful story without really having people and events to hang his tale on. The Time Traveler’s Guide to Medieval England was incredibly interesting.

Posted in Book Reviews, Non-Fiction, Food, History | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | Leave a comment